Stinker from an old timer

Note: I have redacted names, callsigns and dates in the narrative 

It was surprised to see an email titled "Interference with XXXX". Here it is in its entirety.

Hello Ram,

I have to admit, I am a bit disappointed you started operating on the frequency I was using this evening. Especially with another SKCC member. I am operating a Special event Station (XXX) on x.044 @XX:XX this evening. Worst of all, you never first check to see if the frequency was clear (QRL?). If you had I would have zero beat to your freq to let you know I was there operating. Back in the day we all listened first, then put out a QRL. I realize with more crowded bands and younger hams getting their ticket in a weekend, and lack of ELMERS, it becomes paramount to be more courteous than ever. Since you took over the frequency I was operating, I will bow to you and stop operating the Special event station so you can operate your more important POTA. In the future, I kindly ask that you listen first, then send out a QRL to double check the frequency is in use before you just take it. 

--73--

XXX

I was a little shaken. I was saying to myself what did you do? Did I stomp on someone else? So hurriedly I look up the log and found that I was operating 500Hz above the frequency mentioned. Even though the tone of the email irritated me and made some unreasonable assumptions about my operations (such as not putting out QRLs) , I sent the following reply

XXX,

Rechecked XXX XX. I see no spots for me on x44 for me around the time frame.  All spots for me are on x44.5. Please see attached image. I usually shy away from round number frequencies especially when on the field. I typically operate 5w QRP or at most 10W on bad days. I was 10W that day with a simple wire antenna on the tree.  As a QRP operator I have been run out of the frequency many a time by inconsiderate operators and contesters some of whom are old timers from the halcyon age you allude to. So let's not tar and feather the whole crop of newer operators as there are examples of bad operators of varying tenure and skills. I've learnt to grow a thicker skin than having to dwell on that too much. 

Wishing you the best in the future. 

Ram

KE8UEX

73

Note: Not posting the RBN image was attached to the email that indicated the frequency and dates I was operating on.

I was hoping this clarification should be sufficient. However, I get a response indicating that operating 500Hz above on CW is considered stomping on the frequency 500Hz below.  The request now seems to be that I should stay 1KHz from his station. He also acknowledged he heard my QRL and walks back his early accusation of me not doing so. Instead of saying sorry he goes on to patronize me for putting out the QRL 

Hello Ram,

I can understand your response, however, the confusion lies in that I was the one on xx.044 holding QSO's for the special event, not you, In looking at my notes I did hear you start out with QRL, which I replied to let you know I was operating 500Hz below you then you started calling CQ pushing me off a frequency because of other stations not zero beat, which got to the point I had to QSY off. I think the issue may lay in if you were using a CW filter? If you were and most CW filters are usually set around 2-300Hz, which means your filters tight response you would not have heard me because I was out of your window. All I am suggesting, in the future maybe open up your filter a bit when putting out a QRL. I commend you for doing that. As crowded as the bands are today because we now have to share our coveted bands with Chicken banders (CB'ers). I guess, really no harm done since I did a lot of QSO's volunteering for the week long special event station and was only kicked off the frequency once. Hahaha! I appreciate your reply.

This reply irked me further as the as he still insists I was in the wrong. Other than the suggestion about widening the filter the patronizing/dismissive attitude added to the irritation. I sent the following reply. Note it is split into two emails because the send button was hit accidentally during composition

xxx,

You said: the confusion lies in that I was the one on x.044...

There is no confusion here.  I clearly understood your original missive. I am responding to your unjust accusations you raised in your original email.

You said: I am a bit disappointed you started operating on the frequency I was using this evening. 

This is clearly not borne out by the evidence I have presented. Operating 500Hz above you on CW is in no way operating on your frequency. This is at the highest end of ARRL recommendations for separation of 150-500Hz separation between stations. This should accommodate even the most egregious non zero-beaters.

You said: Worst of all, you never first check to see if the frequency was clear (QRL?). 

I see that you recanted this in the subsequent email. I understand apologizing is hard, but I appreciate you conceding that this was also an unfounded accusation not based on facts.

You said:  ... it becomes paramount to be more courteous than ever... I will bow to you and stop operating the Special event station so you can operate your more important POTA

Courtesy should extend beyond the air. While I understand the irritation of operating in crowded bands, I respectfully push back on the tone in your original email. I'm sure if you were sitting across from me you would not have used that tone. I'm not sure where the condescension for POTA operations come from given that you're an active POTA hunter as well. I also believe operating special event station does not confer any special privileges on the amateur bands. 

You said in the later email:  All I am suggesting, in the future maybe open up your filter a bit when putting out a QRL
A good suggestion that I may consider especially when expecting a lot of vintage gears on the air. I still do believe expecting a 1MHz separation for CW operations seems a little bit excessive.

You said: we now have to share our coveted bands with Chicken banders (CB'ers)

You said:  really no harm done since I did a lot of QSO's volunteering for the week long special event 

I am glad that you had a successful event. I did have a great outing at the park that day as well. I still wonder if QSYing was such a non event, what prompted the vitriolic email in the first place. 

===== THE SECOND EMAIL TO COMPLETE THE ONE ABOVE

xxx,

Sorry the previous reply was unfinished. Few corrections and the completion of the email follows: 

I said: . I still do believe expecting a 1MHz separation for CW operations seems a little bit excessive

It should read 1KHz

You said: we now have to share our coveted bands with Chicken banders (CB'ers)

I try to stay away from in-group and out-group thinking. We amateur radio operators work with what we have been granted

Hope you have fun on the air

73

Ram

KE8UEX

To which I got the classiest of replies from a courteous old-timer

It's clear we think differently, and no sense wasting anymore of my time with you. 

--73--

This goes on to prove age and wisdom does not equate to class. If this operator believes he is trying to educate other hams, taking a softer tone initially would probably fall on more receptive ears. For whatever it is worth, this operator has impressive credentials in the QRZ page which I otherwise respect. His sense of entitlement... I do not.

Humble Pi(e) day!

 Saturday, March 14 2026 [3/14]. For some math enthusiasts who subscribe to the US centric view of writing dates, it is Pi day. For some ham radio enthusiasts like me it was strange day with weird propagation.

I started of the day to get my early morning CW fix. Nothing like beginning the day with a good ragchew QSO. On weekends, I usually lurk on the 80m bands very early in the morning and then switch on to 40m as the propagation there gets better.  But today, the bands were flat and I did not hear any of the regulars on the band. This early harbinger should have informed me to be the tough band conditions that day.

But the information did not percolate in. Instead, I spent some time solving the New York Times Crossword and their other puzzles. A little while later, my wife wanted me to run some errands. Unwilling to let this chance go by, I decided to go in for a POTA activation. However, I was not prepared for how rough the bands were. It usually takes me about 20-30 minutes to rustle up 10 contacts. What should have been a quick 30 minute detour into the park turned into a 90 minute nailbiter. I hopped all over the bands. Very few CQs were answered. I knew that if I waited for someone to contact me after hearing my CQ it was going to take much longer to get my 10 contacts. I decided to answer the CQs of other POTA activators. I usually do not do that as I am at topped out at 10W on my POTA setup. I cannot compete with the KW stations in a pileup. But today, it was different. It was a mix of desperation and desire to help out other activators facing rough conditions. Most hunters decidedly stayed away due to rough band conditions; there was no pileup. It was miraculous that some of the POTA stations heard me. I eventually ended up with 11 contacts with about 7 of them being park-to-park QSOs initiated from my end.

I reflected on the day and wondered why I even decided for an activation that day. Then I realized this was perhaps due to the strange propagation I experienced earlier in the day. I was looking at my RBN reports of my CQs on 40m in the morning. I noticed that while most of the usual stations in the 300-600 mile range did not hear me, I was heard loud and clear in ZL. Perhaps I was hoping for a first ZL contact from the park. Perhaps one day that dream would come true!

Ten or nothing!

Ever since I picked up ham radio and POTA, I have tended to seek out opportunities park activations any time I travel. I have also learned to try and make activations as unobtrusive as possible when travelling with family. For example, I would attempt to plan our route so that park activations coincide with breaks in our road trip. That gives the family an opportunity to stretch out their legs in a park, while I try to nab a quick activation. 

Recently, I had an opportunity to travel to California. This was going to be a short overnight trip and I was going solo. That freed me considerably in scheduling my activations. I was flying into John Wayne International in Orange County around 11:00 am. The wedding reception I was attending was at 6:00 pm and the hotel room was only available at 4:00pm. 

On the day before the travel, I decided to take my KH-1 with me as that is the only radio that will fit in my luggage for this trip. I looked around the maps and found that Crystal Cove State Park was about 15 miles from the airport. Since I had a rental car, that made it easy. My plan was to pick up the rental and head straight on to the park. I decided to walk along the beach trails and see if I can get an activation at the same time.

The flight out to California and the rental pickup went according to plan. The three hour time difference between the east coast and the west meant that I was ravishingly hungry. I stopped by at a Subway near the park and picked up a footlong. 

To say the park was beautiful would be an understatement. The weather was a near perfect 78F (26C) . The skies were clear and a beautiful breeze blowing.

I picked a trail that would put me on the beach. I readied my KH-1 and spotted myself on the POTA website. Then I started CQs as I started to walk along the trail. My walk along the trail led to increasingly beautiful views. But the sitrep for the activation was not good. Even after about half an hour of calls; there were no takers. I decided to pack it in. 

As far as busted activations go the situation could not have been better. Ten contacts or more would have been the ideal situation. However, having no contacts means I do not have to log it to the POTA website.  My POTA record(?) will not be tarnished (gasp!) with yet another busted activation! I thoroughly enjoyed the walk and the scenery could not have been more uplifting. You will find a few pictures below and I hope you would agree with me. 

Along the Beach trail at Crystal Cove State Park

Boardwalk at Crystal Cove

Gifted

Father's day! June 15, 2025. Time to saddle up and ride. Performed the safety check on bike:  Brakes, clutch, tires, lights and flashers -- roger. Radio and CW paddle: roger; Antenna and cables: roger, Battery and power cables: roger; log book: roger,  snack pack: roger. All set to go!

I ride to the park close to my QTH : About a 30 minute ride. I arrive at my usual spot in the park; then duck walk my motorcycle back into the slot. I proceeded to shed my gloves, helmet and riding jacket and look up at my usual tree. All's well except for the table. I moved the picnic table out of the direct sunlight into the shady part under the tree; making sure I will be in the shade for the next couple of hours. Moving picnic tables on grassy surface sure was hard work. After catching my breath and resolving to get into better shape, I throw the arborist line up the tree and get my wire antenna ready. Setting up the KX-3 was quick. Time to put out CQs. The bands have not been great these days and I wanted to spot myself on the POTA website. I reach out to my pocket to fish my cell phone out. My brain did not expect the feeling of emptiness in the pocket. Hmmm...no phone. Did I drop it on the way? Or did I leave it at home. After the initial panic, I tried to recall my departure. Did I take my phone or not? After some thinking I realized I did not verify that I took my phone out. I must have left it on the charger at home. 

Drats! I did not want to go back home to retrieve it. So it is either abandon the attempt or power through it. I opted to stay. I started my CQ sequence. My hope is that I can get a responder to spot me. I resolved to complete the activation irrespective of how long it took. 

I was getting increasingly despondent as my CQs went unanswered. As I was surveying my environs I spotted a car making its way slowly through the parking lot. It bore an uncanny resemblance to my vehicle. You know the feeling you get when you spot another vehicle on the road that is the same make and model as yours? There is a fleeting and tenuous feeling of kinship that seems to bind you to the other driver. You're curious about the other person who made the same choice as you. You want to at least get a look at the other person. I had the same feeling here especially where the color choice was also identical.

The car wound its way through the parking lot. After a few moments, it was making a beeline towards me. Hmm..this is interesting. As the car got closer, I realized it was my son who was driving it. He had realized I left my phone at home and had made the trip to the park to hand if off to me! Needless to say I was dumbfounded. A better Father's day gift I could not imagine!

Ruined?

 I have always had mixed feelings mixing radio with vacations. My experience in mixing radio with vacation was not always a pleasant one [https://motopota.blogspot.com/2024/05/oil-and-water.html] . But as I clicked on the button to reserve our tickets to the UK earlier this year, I knew in the back of my mind that my baggage would contain a HF radio. As a bonus, our tickets included checked in baggage. That would mean I would be able to pack my JPC-12 vertical antenna with a ground spike should I need better reach.

I knew I would not have much time for activation. So I decided to stick with my KH-1. We landed in London and it was a pretty busy couple of days. The KH-1 was always with me as we were walking around the city. Surprisingly most attractions were not even interested in the radio when they performed the baggage check. They just wanted to know what it was and I was on my merry way. Even the Supreme court of the UK permitted me through with my radio. Only the British Museum security would not permit the radio to be taken inside. However, they were very polite and offered to hold it for me during my visit. I took them upon it with a little trepidation, but was glad when I was rejoined with my radio upon my exit.

As we were strolling through Hyde Park on one of the days, I decided to try out the KH-1. I heard many stations primarily on 20m. They were mostly from continental Europe, but my attempt to reach back did not elicit much success. The urban conditions and the propagation were against a QRP radio that time.

Unfortunately, that was the only opportunity to play radio during our three day sojourn in London. But the sights and sounds of the city more than made up for this minor setback. 

Soon it was time to depart London and head our way to Edinburgh! My itinerary had some time through the Scottish highlands later. It took me through a couple of POTA entities and I thought I can try and get an activation coincident with a lunch break as we drove along. However, we arrived in Edinburgh early in the evening to a typical Scottish weather. It was blustery with on and off showers. Our son was supposed to join us later in the day, so we had a few hours to ourselves. As we settled into the hotel, I check the POTA map and found out that Calton Hill in the city was within a POTA entity. It was a few minutes away from my hotel and my wife and I felt the walk would do us good after the train journey. It was a steep climb to up to the hill. We were rewarded with great sights overlooking Edinburgh. We strolled through the Greek architecture and towards sunset, I decided to try the KH-1 again. This time as well I was hearing quite a few stations, but none could hear me. RBN reports were also not that great. The blustery winds and oncoming rain forced me to call it quits and head back to the hotel.

The weather would not be our friend. As we travelled through the Highlands we encountered heavy downpours during the midday hours. The much anticipated POTA activation of the park eluded me. 

However, I still did not lose hope. Our itinerary included driving back from Inverness back to Cambridge and then on to London. Our son was a history buff and insisted that we stop by Antonine Wall. Bingo.. This was my opportunity. The early Roman ruins was also a POTA entity. The place was perfect..

As we strolled along the park taking in the sights, I was able to use my KH-1 and rustle up enough contacts for a successful activation. Despite the tiredness at the end of the day, all of us enjoyed this little detour. I especially was ecstatic as I was able to snag my first overseas park in addition to enjoying the beautiful ruins. The 150 mile trip to our next planned stop did not seem daunting any more.

Alinco strikes again

Saturday, June 7, 2025! And not just an ordinary Saturday. It was the day for the annual Michigan POTA meetup.  This year the meet up was at Fort Custer Recreation Area (US-3310). I visited the last year's meet up and this year's weather forecast was much better. Although I did not have the time for an overnight camp trip unlike last year, I decided to go in for a day trip. The 250 mile round trip in great weather and the chance to meet up some POTA folks was too good to pass.

I saddled up at about 9:30 am and flat topped it to the park around 11am. In my saddle case was my usual KX-3 POTA set up. However, since the bands have not been that great I decided to go with a little more oomph with my trusty old DX-70. 

When I arrived, the meetup was at full swing. The meeting was well attended and saw people from various parts of the state. After some meet and greet and catching up with acquaintances from the past year I decided to get an activation in. There were some chuckles when I set up the Alinco.  This rig is not in the greatest shape, but I have always been partial to it. It was a rats mess of cables and wires when I had completed hooking up the CW keyer and the antenna tuner. 

I was warned! The bands were bad. I roamed the 40m, 30m and 20m band. Only 40m seemed to have some life in it. Despite running my Alinco at 50W there were very few takers. I was using the JPC-12 vertical. KB6NU who is out of Ann Arbor suggested that I try his doublet antenna instead. He was kind enough to lug it from his car and set it up for me. While the doublet brought in a few more contacts nothing would overcome the pitiable band conditions that day.

Activation at the POTA meetup. Photo Courtesy: MI POTA Meetup

     

But time was on my side. I had an automatic MX-2 type keyer hooked up to the Alinco; so the tedium if putting out repeated CQs was not there. I was mildly mocked for having taken my full size Begali single lever paddle that was hooked to the keyer. Nevertheless, I kept the CQs going through the excellent lunch spread put out by the organizers. Eventually after about 90 minutes, I was proud when the tenth contact rolled in. I was also proud that I did not have to rely on the help of the attendees to make my quota. 

As I was packing my gear in, the raffle tickets organized by the meet up folks were announced. I ended up winning a POTA bumper sticker. This stroke of luck emboldened me to stop by US-1518 on the way back. Yes indeed! My luck held and I was able to get a successful activation there as well.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the MI POTA meetup organizers for putting on a great event. Your enthusiasm is infectious and is greatly appreciated

Resistance is futile!

When I did not feel the comforting resistance when tugging the antenna wire I realized Murphy had struck. The inevitable law chose me for enforcement today!

So here I was with the antenna wire loose in my hand; my arborist throw bag and rope up the tree. My attempt to set up the wire antenna during a park activation was off to a disastrous start. As I pondered and made several attempts to retrieve the rope, I was keeping a wary eye around. I did not want to look like a clown jumping up and down a tree to the other visitors of the park. Eventually I had to give up and resolved to bring a frisbee retriever or a pole to retrieve it later.  I was fortunate that this happened at my "home" park which is only a few miles from my QTH, 

One problem was conveniently pushed under the rug for now.

I then decided to focus on trying to get my activation completed. Fortunately, I was in my car today and noticed the mag-mount antenna was still in the car. Unfortunately, I only had the 40m resonator and whip. I decided to press on any way. Despite the horrendous band conditions, the Hustler resonator and whip did well and I was able to rustle up enough contacts! I paid the cost in the time required to get the contacts. I have noticed that unless the bands are really bad, there is almost always someone who can hear you. One only wishes lady luck is on your side in these conditions. Activiation done!

I have to go back to the park anyway and safely retrieve the throw bag. Another opportunity for an activation!

Edit: 05/03. Today I went back to the park with a pole and safely retrieved the rope and the throw weight. No trees were harmed. I also managed to squeeze an activation in. The bands really took a dip this morning and I was glad I was able to make enough contacts on 40m.